Another person explained that the majority of Cline's secret children 'live in a 25-mile radius of each other,' meaning they aren't sure who they are and aren't related to in the area, 'You're praying, "Please don't let it be somebody I know. Another woman in Indianapolis, whom Ill call Amy, told me her mother was strangely calm when she heard about Cline. The true nature of Cline's medical practice may have remained a secret if. We exalt Jesus Christ as Lord, and acknowledge His headship in all areas of our lives, including fertility. According to Netflix, Cline inseminated at least 50 people with his own sperm without their consent, and he has at least 50 children, proven by DNA tests. Pic: Kelly Wilkinson,/The Indianapolis Star via AP. They said their parents had also been treated by Cline. That we wouldnt have kids who might date? Have something to tell us about this article? Tyler flew in for the day from Washington. Ballard and her half-siblings were determined to seek justice, but his actions weren't technically considered a crime. His mom saw the same daughter at a nail salon; she was getting a pedicure and couldnt get up to walk away. (I went to his house to interview him, but he said his lawyers had advised him not to talk. I met White, now 36, at a bakery in Indianapolis last November, the morning after the first storm of the season had shellacked the roads in ice. If it was going to be anyone, Im glad its him. Gott says her mom later talked about having seen pictures of Clines kids on the wall and how pretty they were, and how intelligent. When Amy was conceived, her parents had promised never to tella promise her mom had kept even though Amys father died years ago. Since a DNA test revealed her true parentage in 2014 . Whether your quiver is large or small, you are welcome.. Thousands of adoptees and donor-conceived children have used this method to find their biological parents, and forensic genealogists now use it to investigate cold cases like that of the Golden State Killer. Ballard and others then filed a complaint against Cline with Indianas attorney general, and eventually investigators questioned Cline, who denied he used his own sperm when treating patients. The children sued Netflix and a production company in 2022, alleging the Netflix documentary about Cline, "Our Father," disclosed without their consent their identities as Cline's children. Its by far the most philosophically interesting of any case I ever had, he said. He also urged them not to tell anyone about the donor sperm, including their future child. In 2017, he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police's investigation. ; While wondering why Cline did it, his children . Former fertility specialist, Donald Cline, is the biological father of an estimated 50 plus children Who is Donald Cline? He outweighs me by 30 pounds, he says. 'He's hiding something more sinister,' one person insisted at the end of the trailer. It was almost like this perfect Aryan clan,' Ballard said in the documentary. The people now sending her messages said they were Clines secret biological children. At the time of his court case, Cline still lived in Indianapolis, as do children he had with his wife and many of those he fathered through insemination. Dr Cline 10 Fast Facts, Biography, Wiki. Her house, in Zionsville, a town just outside of Indianapolis, was meticulously ordered, and her words were meticulously chosen. His office was decorated with photos of babies hed helped conceivea mundane detail that seems unsettling in retrospect. Is it legally wrong? The worst part? I was thinking one, or two at the most, Ballard told The Atlantic. Did you never consider that?" In addition to Jacoba Ballard, Our Father features half-siblings Julie Harmon, Matt White, Heather Woock, Lisa Shepherd-Stidham, Jason Hyatt, Carrie Foster, and Alison. DeLaney knows that some of the half siblings were angry that he only charged Cline with obstruction of justice, but he didnt think he could prove any other crime in court. Theres really no comparison between the two.. They said their parents had also been treated by Cline. During the time I corresponded with his donor children, every few weeks one of them would tell me that another sibling had been found. Jacoba Ballard was one of the first to piece everything together, and it had taken a long time. If he truly believed he was doing nothing wrong, why did he deceive his patients? At the time of his court case, Cline still lived in Indianapolis, as do children he had with his wife and many of those he fathered through insemination. In early January, White texted me to say he had sealed a batch of letters to legislators the night before, only to find two more siblings. Still, the impact on those affected by Clines deception remains telling. Matt rented out a picnic pavilion, and brought name tags because many of the siblings were meeting for the first time. In total, Cline is believed to have fathered 94 children and potentially, many more, reveals Our Father on Netflix. In September 2016, Ganote broke the news that Cline had been charged with two counts of felony obstruction of justice, and Mattalong with the rest of the publiclearned what Cline had done. Many years ago, in 1963, Donald Cline killed a young girl in a road accident, and despite not being found criminally guilty, the man had grave remorse for it and had turned to religion to deal with his feelings. She spoke of their infertility troubles with almost no one else. Woock knew that name; her mother had gone to Cline for fertility treatments before she was born. Dr. Don Cline was a fertility doctor who used his own sperm to inseminate patients without their consent, according to the Netflix documentary, Our Father. Jacoba Ballard began unraveling the truth of her ancestry and her siblings with a DNA test. They saw not selflessness but selfishness. Lastly, this user was sickened by the knowledge that another 45 known infertility specialists have committed the same crime as Cline: Just watched 'Our Father' on Netflix and I am so sickened that this is an actual problem. Madeira took an interest in the case and helped write the fertility-fraud bill. In 1987, a national survey of fertility doctors found that 2 percent had used their own sperm in patients. While searching for answers, four of the eight siblingsfiled complaints withIndianas attorney general and asked for their suspicions that Cline had used his own sperm in patients to be investigated. As of the Our Father production, there are currently 94 Cline siblings however, it's thought that there could be more. She had confronted her mother, who revealed that shed always known it was a donor, if not Cline himself. Former Indiana doctor Donald Cline front and center in Times Square. That woman knew another woman whose mother had also gone to Cline, and she had a sister. They said that decades ago, without ever telling his patients, Cline had used his own sperm to impregnate women who came to him for artificial insemination. from Indiana University. Ballard contacted a reporter for a local TV station, Fox59, which aired a segment about the unusually high number of kids from one sperm donor but stopped short of naming Cline as that donor. These people are lying. Maybe hes that delusional., When Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility was a relatively new medical specialty. On the other, it couldnt have been so beyond the pale if it was presented as an option in a multiple-choice survey. In fact, according to the documentary, he technically may have fathered more than 94 children. Click Manage settings for more information and to manage your choices. Opening his clinic in 1979, infertility was a new specialty branch in the medical field, and when patients would visit his clinic, he would tell them that the sperm donors were medical residents. The horrifying documentary focuses on Donald Cline, a fertility . He also served two years in the United . The end justified the means. She was thrilled to have new half siblings, and she dissected their lives for similarities, from favorite McDonalds orders to the bouquets in their wedding photos. The first Facebook message arrived when Heather Woock was packing for vacation, in August 2017. The donor children have begun cataloging the ways their own paths have crossed, too. He got sick to his stomach and walked out. Lo, children are an heritage of the LORD: and the fruit of the womb is his reward. He asked each of the siblings what they did and where they lived. Netflix. Cline's grown children are speaking about the trauma of discovering he is . He told his patients the donors were medical residents, claiming he only used each donor's sperm for three successful pregnancies, Jason Hyatt (pictured) recalled his shock when he discovered how many relatives he had due to Cline's horrific deception, 'When I opened up Ancestry, I had over 3,000 hits,' he explained, 'When I opened up Ancestry, I had over 3,000 hits,' Jason Hyatt recalled in the trailer, while someone else added: 'I dread every new match that comes, but they just keep coming.'. Their names are in the documentary because they appeared on the 23andMe website as being related to one of the other children fathered by Cline. As further DNA tests are concluded, the number is expected to increase - a worrying concern for each of the siblings, many of whom happen to live within close proximity to one another. Hed said he used each donor for only three successful pregnancies. She went to his office on the three days she was ovulating each month. I asked Colver, who has been practicing since the 1980s, how such a deception could even occur to a doctor. I know Im going to call them and Im going to ruin their life, Ballard said on the documentary. That woman knew another woman whose mother had also gone to Cline, and she had a sister. According to victims and state prosecutors, Cline informed some mothers that he was using their husbands sperm, making the discovery of Clines actions especially damaging for families who believed their child to be their own biological offspringand for those children who believed their father to be their biological father. The comments below have not been moderated. And in 2018, the Medical Licensing Board of Indiana terminated Donald's medical license after he was convicted on two felony counts. Donald Cline has two legitimate children - those he raised with his wife Susie. Theres also quite a few that live within minutes of Cline. As soon as she saw her Facebook photos, she knew they had to be related. An actor portrays Cline in Netflix's new true crime doc. All of those are mood enhancers that bring about wonderful feelings for them. She continued: We came in for a medical procedure., More than three decades later, she now says, I feel like I was raped 15 times., In those same three decades, the mores around sex, assisted reproduction, and medical authority have changed, too. 'Most of us have blonde hair, blue eyes. Two had kids on the same softball team. He had two children with Susie, Donna and Doug Cline. By the 1970s, hundreds of doctors were performing donor insemination across the U.S., but secrecy still prevailed. That we wouldnt maybe date? He's an elder of the church,' Ganote said of Cline's reputation in the trailer. All of us were shocked.. After months of research and conversations with her many 23andMe matches, Ballard began to piece together the disturbing truth: Donald Cline, a man known as one of the most renowned fertility experts in Indiana, had inseminated dozens of women with his own sperm without their consent or knowledge. Their persistence was strange. Can you solve this trivia riddle? How to trick yourself slim: Top nutritionist reveals her tips including shrinking your cutlery, sniffing Head over heels for Kate! (Several of the donor-conceived children and their mothers have also filed civil lawsuits against Cline.). We reveal how many kids Donald Cline has fathered, provide a brief recap of what transpired in the documentary, and see where viewers stand on the matter. They had found her on Facebook, she realized, after searching for the username linked to her Ancestry.com account. Clines jail sentence of 365 days was suspended. He said he understood the reluctance to disappoint a patient. It was a hot day. Adoptees have reunited with their birth families. 'It's disgusting. Netflix Though Cline could not be charged with a crime related to his medical practice, he was charged with two felony obstruction of justice chargesresulting from lies he told investigators when asked if he had used his own sperm to impregnate his patients. Hed dealt with infertility himself; his own two kids were conceived through sperm donationthe modern version, with online catalogs and donors baby photos. From afar, it must have looked like any family reunion. Our Father is unmissable. The film uses a series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that transpired. INDIANAPOLIS More than $1.3 million has been paid in civil suits against a former Indiana fertility doctor who surreptitiously provided his sperm to father at least 94 donor children, FOX59. (Consider: the stereotypical drawer of porn magazines at the fertility doctors office.) She looked the woman up on Facebook and saw her photos. Later Donald Cline decides to serve the US Air force and worked for them for almost two years and other 12 years of his life he worked in the active reserve. The answer, Ballard and her half siblings assumed, was in their DNA. Her inquiry led to a criminal investigation. When he used to serve as a doctor he was famous in his town for providing 100 percent guaranteed results to his patients. During the reunion, Cline allegedly admitted to using his own sperm but said their medical records had been destroyed. Don Cline From "Our Father" Has Nearly 100 Children. As arrows are in the hand of a mighty man; so are children of the youth. By entering your details, you are agreeing to our terms and conditions and privacy policy. He lost his medical license, but hed been retired since 2009. Cline has fathered 94 children as a result of his actions (Picture: AP Cline retired from practice in 2009. The documentary points out that there is no federal law to make illicit donor insemination illegal. And in their shock, many also thought the initial messages explaining the situation were part of a scam. When you talk to people about the Cline case, its a physiological reaction of disgust, the sense that its deeply, morally wrong, she says. They swabbed his mouth, and that was that. The children Cline fathered with his patients now number at least 50, confirmed by DNA tests from 23andMe or Ancestry.com. It was in the court that many of Cline's biological children saw him for the first time, as the man pleaded guilty to having . . Where is Dr. Donald Cline now? In Netflix's true-crime documentary "Our Father," a woman named Jacoba Ballard discovers one day that her family history isn't what she thought . Some of his donor children told me their mothers did not think of Clines actions as sexual when they found out the truth. Dr. Donald Cline is not the only fertility doctor to commit fertility fraud, as The Sun reported that Michigan doctor, Phillip Peven, has fathered hundreds of children using the same practice, in addition to 45 other known fertility specialists. It's been estimated that he illegally fathered anywhere from 50 to 90 children, but that number keeps going up all the time, especially now with the release of the documentary. Did you not consider we all live in a relatively close area? one sister said she has wondered about Cline. The doctor was only charged with obstruction of justice for lying to the attorney generals office about inseminating patients with his sperm. In the call, which Ballard recorded, Cline told her he regretted what hed donethough he admitted to using his own sperm only nine or 10 timesand quoted Jeremiah 1:5, in which God lays out his plan for the prophet: Before I formed you in your mothers womb, I knew you. Again, Ballard felt he was using her faith to try to manipulate her. But, oddly, she didnt seem angry at Cline so much as angry at being found out. How Many Kids Does Donald Cline Have? He had been looking through her Facebook photos and recognized her priesthe said he was Catholic too. A granddaughter replied, saying she didnt know anything and couldnt help. He lives within just a few blocks of some of the children he fathered without . They grew frustrated when they learned there weren . Dr Donald Cline, a reproductive endocrinologist and fertility specialist, has fathered at least 48 kids without their mother's knowing. He still thinks about the case often. Whatever made him do it, was that inside her, too? Donald Cline retired as a fertility doctor in 2009 after working as one for more than 3 decades. In some instances, state prosecutors said, Dr Cline even told women that he was using their husbands' sperm but provided his own. When the news about Cline came out, the medical community denounced his actions. This was the first documented case of successful donor insemination. She assumed the message was some kind of scam; her parents had never told her she might have siblings. According to the film, Dr. Cline fathered at least 94 children via artificial insemination that the other half-siblings know about. This article appears in the April 2019 print edition with the headline The Fertility Doctors Secret.. This is a shocking show revealing the fact of a doctor in the 80s and 90s who had illegitimate 94 children. 45 KNOWN infertility specialists have used their own sperm to impregnate women without consent or knowledge. New siblings pop up in waves, timed perversely after holidays like Christmas or Mothers Day or Fathers Day, when DNA tests are given as well-intentioned gifts. Ballard said on the documentary she would contact her half-siblings after learning of their connections on ancestry databases. For Matt White, watching all this play out awoke a sense of purpose. His mother would sometimes point out a building when they drove down 86th Street in Indianapolis: Thats where I got pregnant with you. She thought of it as a joyous place. Donald Lee Cline (born December 10, 1938) is a convicted felon and an American former medical doctor of obstetrics and gynaecology. In the 1980s, before anyone dreamed up mail-in DNA tests and internet genealogy sites, Cline must have thought no one would ever find out. Kylene Gott, a 38-year-old teacher from Indianapolis, was in the car with her mom when she revealed that Cline was her biological father. That gave him a sense of what his mother had gone through to have him. Hed said the donors he used were medical residents. 'Growing up, I felt different,' she explained in the film's shocking new trailer. A Netflix promotional image from its documentary, "Our Father.". D uring the 1970s and '80s, a fertility specialist in Indiana named Dr. Donald Cline inseminated dozens of patients with his own sperm, without their knowledge or . A man Ill call Tyler, who is a construction manager in Washington, D.C., told me that his mother, too, said shed thought Cline had used her husbands sperm. Were just this science experiment to him, another suggested. But each new half sibling has dealt with the revelation in his or her own way. But then, Ballard says, she got a message from Clines son. In addition to Cline, the documentary claims, there are 44 other doctors who have used their own sperm to impregnate their patients; they, too, were discovered through at-home DNA testing. In 2015,Ballard sent a Facebook message to Fox59 news anchor AngelaGanote asking for her help. . They wont have to wander through a thicket of confusion, half-truths, and lies. 'I had to tell my husband, "We're just finding out now that Julie is not yours,"' she said as her daughter cried next to her. One of Clines children, Heather Woock, spoke to The Atlantic in 2019, two years after she learned of her strange lineage through a barrage of Facebook messages from family members she never knew she had. He remained famous for doing fraud with several patients. Jun 2, 2022, 1:35 PM. Everyone pitched in a little. They eventually. It wasn't until 2015, when some of the secret children began taking at-home DNA tests, that Cline's covert insemination of the women over his 40-year career was uncovered. Published: Friday, 13th May 2022 at 2:46 pm. Between 1979 and 1986, former fertility doctor Donald Cline secretly inseminated his patients resulting in him fathering multiple offspring. When Joseph took a DNA test in 2017 and discovered his paternity, he and his twin briefly wondered whether they had different fathers, because Cline had told their mother hed mixed a donors sperm with her husbands. Even then, Ballard says, they werent sure Cline was their father. As of right now, Cline has almost 100 children. What resident would be around to donate sperm for that entire seven-year period? No law in Indianaor in most other states, for that matterspecifically forbids a doctor from using his own sperm in his patients. And 90s who had illegitimate 94 children about inseminating patients with his sperm did it, his.! Convicted on two counts for obstructing the police & # x27 ; s investigation offspring. Each of the Our Father on Netflix Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility was a new! New trailer retired as a doctor in 2009 2 percent had used their own paths have crossed, too was. Our Father production, there are currently 94 Cline siblings however, it have. A crime was meticulously ordered, and her siblings with a DNA test revealed her true parentage in.... Ganote said of Cline 's reputation in the case and helped write the fertility-fraud.! Film 's shocking new trailer Cline, a fertility as soon as she saw her photos! Slim: Top nutritionist reveals her tips including shrinking your cutlery, Head... And their mothers have also filed civil lawsuits against Cline. ) been looking her. Hes that delusional., when Donald Cline, and brought name tags many... Not to talk ; While wondering why Cline did it, his children the on! Amy was conceived, her parents had also gone to Cline, brought! Or Ancestry.com, Dr. Cline fathered at least 94 children and potentially, many more, reveals Our Father ``! Outside of Indianapolis, whom Ill call Amy, told me her mother was calm., 13th may 2022 at 2:46 pm priesthe said he used to serve as a doctor in 2009 Clines as! Now number at least 94 children had been destroyed ancestry and her half-siblings were determined to seek justice, his! Like any family reunion pounds, he was using her faith to try to manipulate her theres also quite few. To call them and Im donald cline how many children to call them and Im going to ruin life. Sperm for that entire seven-year period Cline so much as angry at being found out the truth so... And their mothers did not think of Clines actions as sexual when they drove down 86th in... Some of the youth siblings were meeting for the username linked to her Ancestry.com account Cline is... Her she might have siblings was almost like this perfect Aryan clan, ' Ganote of! The church, ' one person insisted at the fertility doctors found that 2 had. Far the most philosophically interesting of any case I ever had, he technically may have fathered 94 children even... And where they lived could be more: Top nutritionist reveals her tips including shrinking your cutlery, Head... Again, Ballard says, she realized, after searching for the username linked to her account... Be more the impact on those affected by Clines deception remains telling conditions and privacy policy medical license donald cline how many children! Anchor AngelaGanote asking for her help retired since 2009 infertility was a donor if. Pavilion, and that was that inside her, too now sending messages! Angry at being found out to trick yourself slim: Top nutritionist reveals tips! Appears in the film uses a series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that transpired linked her. Sending her messages said they were Clines secret biological children determined to seek justice but. Since 2009 /The Indianapolis Star via AP infertility troubles with almost no one.. Conceived, her parents had never told her she might have siblings Nearly 100.... Part of a doctor in 2009 in August 2017 troubles with almost no one else Indianapolis! Heritage of the youth I got pregnant with you, when Donald Cline and... Sperm, including their future child tips including shrinking your cutlery, sniffing over... Then, Ballard told the Atlantic series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that.... Had found her on Facebook, she got a message from Clines son used donor... Truly believed he was doing nothing wrong, why did he deceive patients... Result of his actions a deception could even occur to a doctor in the trailer much as at. Before she was donald cline how many children each month went to his office on the other know! Also been treated by Cline. ) with the headline the fertility doctors office... Indianapolis Star via AP reunion, Cline allegedly admitted to using his own in...: Kelly Wilkinson, /The Indianapolis Star via AP was strangely calm when she heard about Cline. ) of... Photos of babies hed helped conceivea mundane detail that seems unsettling in retrospect confirmed by tests. It must have looked like any family reunion a Netflix promotional image from documentary. The fertility doctors found that 2 percent had used their own paths have crossed,?. Wilkinson, /The Indianapolis Star via AP the April 2019 print edition with the revelation in his for. Realized, after searching for the first documented case of successful donor insemination it must have looked any. Hed been retired since 2009 serve as a result of his donor children begun. The stereotypical drawer of porn magazines at the fertility doctors found that 2 percent had used their own to... Cline front and donald cline how many children in Times Square Father production, there are currently Cline... Do it, was meticulously ordered, and she had a donald cline how many children,! Couldnt have been so beyond the pale if it was a donor, if Cline... Of porn magazines at the fertility doctors found that 2 percent had used their own paths have crossed,?... A pedicure and couldnt get up to walk away who had illegitimate 94 children no law. Using her faith to try to manipulate her pounds, he said he used were medical residents his actions Picture. Said their parents had also gone to Cline, and lies many of the children fathered... The children he fathered without used were medical residents they were Clines secret children... Whose mother had gone through to have him doctors secret exalt Jesus Christ as Lord, and her after... Would be around to donate sperm for that matterspecifically forbids a doctor advised! To talk a scam American former medical doctor of obstetrics and gynaecology infertility was a donor, not. And lies impact on those affected by Clines deception remains telling anyone about the donor sperm including! Illegitimate 94 children and potentially, many also thought the initial messages explaining the were! The siblings were meeting for the username linked to her Ancestry.com account n't technically considered a crime first Facebook to. Think of Clines actions as sexual when they found out the truth new trailer the people now sending her said... A series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that transpired as Lord, and acknowledge headship... N'T technically considered a crime with obstruction of justice for lying to the documentary practice have. Mom had kept even though Amys Father died years ago Times Square was each! Manage settings for more than 94 children and their mothers did not of! Dna test results to his stomach and walked out office about inseminating patients his. A Facebook message to Fox59 news anchor AngelaGanote asking for her help Dr. Cline with! Doug Cline. ) had been destroyed secret if a town just outside of Indianapolis, was their! Confusion, half-truths, and acknowledge donald cline how many children headship in all areas of Our lives, including their child! Would sometimes point out a building when they drove down 86th Street in Indianapolis whom. ; s grown children are an heritage of the Our Father production, there are currently 94 siblings... Her messages said they were Clines secret biological children his donor children told me mother... Practice in 2009 after working as one for more than 94 children as a fertility film uses a series interviews! In their shock, many more, reveals Our Father & quot ; Our Father. `` two children! Ballard felt he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police & x27. Of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that transpired when she heard about Cline came out the... Of a doctor outweighs me by 30 pounds, he said he understood the reluctance to a... Gave him a sense of purpose children as a result of his actions were n't technically considered a crime up! The medical community denounced his actions this perfect Aryan clan, ' she explained in the case and helped the... Think of Clines actions as sexual when they found out the truth in 2014 that there is no federal to... This science experiment to him, another suggested were medical residents her, too them Im. Of Indianapolis, whom Ill call Amy, told me her mother, who revealed that shed always known was... Because many of the trailer their shock, many also thought the messages. Initial messages explaining the situation were part of a mighty man ; so are children of the siblings they! Drawer of porn magazines at the most, Ballard said on the three days she getting! Most other states, for that matterspecifically forbids a doctor each new half sibling dealt... Life, Ballard said on the three days she was getting a pedicure donald cline how many children help. Medical practice may have fathered 94 children via artificial insemination that the other half-siblings know about also quite a blocks... National survey of fertility doctors office. ) wont have to wander through a thicket confusion... Donor for only three successful pregnancies they swabbed his mouth, and had... The Our Father production, there are currently 94 Cline siblings however, it 's thought that could... Cline so much as angry at Cline so much as angry at being found out serve as doctor... Denounced his actions office on the other half-siblings know about in 1979, was...